At a Glance 

• Science-backed dose
• Third-party tested
• No artificial dyes or fillers
• Subscribe-and-save available

Create Creatine Gummies easily earned our top recommendation due to their clinically dosed, easy-to-read formulation and incredible taste. They use creatine monohydrate and contain 4.5 grams of creatine in a serving size of three gummies. The chewable supps are also vegan, non-GMO, and gluten-free, earning a 4 out of 5 for formulation. Each serving contains 60 calories, 8 grams of carbohydrates, and 5 grams of sugar (2 grams of added sugar).

I love that Create gummies are third-party tested for contaminants and banned substances, as well as manufactured in an FDA-approved facility. Former GGR product tester and editorial team member Kate Meier tells me, “These are a super fun treat!”

Taste: 5/5

Texture: 5/5

Third-Party Testing: 5/5

Why We Like Create Creatine Gummies

We love that these contain 1.5 grams of creatine per gummy—more than many, which often top out at 1 gram per gummy—so you only need three gummies to reach the high end of the clinically validated dose of 3 to 5 grams. Create uses Creapure, which is a trusted creatine monohydrate form that’s widely used across top supplements.

Other ingredients include tapioca syrup, sugar, water, pectin, malic acid, natural flavors, and natural color, which are all things I’d expect to find in gummy candy for taste and texture. 

Kate says, “They definitely taste like an orange gummy; not quite as sweet as candy, but pretty darn close—really pleasant. I love a gummy. I wish every supplement came in gummy form.” She rates the taste at a perfect 5 out of 5. Kate also experienced no unwanted effects post-consumption, warranting Create gummies another 5-out-of-5 rating for side effects.

If you’re hesitant about trying creatine gummies, Create can be a good option to try because they offer full refunds if you’re not satisfied with your purchase. Yes, they’ll even refund you if the product is opened. 

RELATED: How Long Does Creatine Stay in Your System?

Alternatives

While the formula mostly consists of things that are necessary for a gummy, they do contain 2 grams of added sugars. This is far from the most we’ve seen, sugar-wise, but it’s worth knowing for those watching their intake.  

At $60 for 30 servings, these are on the expensive side, as well (roughly $2 per serving). However, Create does offer a subscribe-and-save option, which brings the price down to $48 for 30 servings. It’s worth signing up if you like them (and don’t mind automatic reorders). 

Want a full 5-gram dose from your creatine gummies? Try Legion Naturally Sweetened & Flavored Creatine Monohydrate Gummies.

Testing Breakdown

Create Creatine Gummies scored highly in every category except in terms of cost, but that’s the price you pay for a top-tier, independently certified product. 

Vs. The Average

Create gummies are slightly more expensive than average, but come with the benefit of getting a full creatine dose in a smaller, more approachable serving size. 

At a Glance 

• Subscribe-and-save available
• 8 flavors to choose from
• Full clinically validated 5-g dose of creatine
• Sweet and slightly tangy

Known for producing high-quality supplements like Pulse pre-workout and Whey+ protein, Legion knocked it out of the park (again) with the brand’s easy-to-chew creatine gummies. Snagging our recommendation for the best creatine monohydrate gummies due to the research-approved 5-gram dose, they’re available in eight flavors.

Our tester—Director of Content and CPT Nicole Davis—tried the OG flavor, Lemon Drop, and notes, “I love that they’re third-party tested and taste great, to boot.” You can view the Labdoor test results on Legion’s website, and this level of transparency helped them earn a 5 out of 5 for third-party testing.

Taste: 4/5

Third-Party Testing: 5/5

Customer Experience: 5/5

Why We Like Legion Naturally Sweetened & Flavored Creatine Monohydrate Gummies

With no artificial sweeteners, fillers, or dyes, these tasty creatine gummies deliver 5 grams of creatine per serving, earning a perfect 5-out-of-5 formulation score. On the brand’s website, Legion notes that its products are made in NSF-certified and FDA-inspected facilities, which should give you further peace of mind about what you’re putting into your body.

These gummies check the box when it comes to taste, too, and Nicole rates them at 4 out of 5 in this all-important category. “They’re not super citrusy—more sweet than tangy, but I actually quite like them,” Nicole says. She rates them a 4 out of 5 for swallowability/texture, as well, adding, “They do get stuck in your teeth a little bit, as they’re a little soft and sticky, but it’s not horrible.”

We also love that the creatine source in these gummies is creatine monohydrate, which is the most extensively studied form of supplemental creatine. So, you know you’re reaping all of the known benefits of creatine when you use these Legion gummies.

At about $45 for a 30-serving bottle, these gummies also rank highly in terms of price and overall value. While there are cheaper options available, $1.67 per serving is solid for gummies (earning a 3 out of 5 for its cost), which tend to be more expensive than powdered creatine monohydrate. You can also subscribe for recurring monthly orders to drop the price further.

Plus, if you’re not satisfied with these gummies (even though we think you will be), you can get a full refund through Legion’s “No Return Necessary” money-back guarantee. That’s what we call top-notch customer service.

Alternatives

Do note that a full serving of five gummies contains 8 grams of added sugar. We know that’s what makes them taste so good, but individuals watching their sugar intake may want to skip this product. Registered dietitian Destini Moody was not thrilled about this, saying, “Coming from a brand like Legion—who is known for naturally sweetened supplements that put health before profit—I was shocked to see 8 grams of sugar per serving from two different sources that also happen to be the first two ingredients.”

Additionally, Destini points out that the serving size is large and, “Not ideal for people who don’t like sweets or generally a mouth full of gummies.”

For Legion fans who prefer their creatine in liquid form, check out Legion Recharge. This creatine powder from Legion Athletics is a post-workout drink, but comes in several great-tasting flavors.

Testing Breakdown

One of the highest-scoring creatine gummy products overall, Legion impressed our testers with its full 5-gram dose of creatine, independent testing, and 100% money-back guarantee.

Vs. The Average

Legion gummies cost $0.20 more than the average price per serving for creatine gummies. However, they have a 0.5-gram edge on the average dose of creatine per serving.  

Read our full Legion Creatine Gummies review for more details.

At a Glance 

• High 5-g dose of creatine monohydrate
• One of the most cost-effective gummy options
• 4 flavors available
• Sugar-free option contains sugar alcohols

If you’re looking for a convenient gummy form of creatine that you can easily add to your next Amazon purchase, Jacked Factory Creatine Gummies can be an excellent choice. With Amazon’s subscribe-and-save feature, they cost just $26 per container, which also makes them one of the most budget-friendly options at under $1 per serving. This cost-effectiveness, combined with the ease of ordering from Amazon (especially if you’re a Prime member), earn them a 5 out of 5 for customer experience.

They’re available in three flavors—Blue Raspberry, Lemon, Watermelon, and Green Apple—and contain 5 grams of creatine monohydrate per serving. 

RELATED: Best Protein Powder on Amazon

Taste: 4/5

Third-Party Testing: 3/5

Texture: 4/5

Why We Like Jacked Factory Creatine Gummies

These gummies earned 4 out of 5 stars for taste from our tester, Nicole Davis, CPT, PN1-NC. “These have a tang, which I like, but I wouldn’t guess they were Blue Raspberry,” Nicole states. “They taste like tangy fruit. They have a little bit of an artificial taste, but it’s not bad at all!”

“These are much firmer than other gummies I’ve tested and don’t get stuck in my teeth as easily,” she adds. “They are a little grainy feeling, though, so I’m giving them 4 out of 5 stars even though I like the texture, overall.”

The Jacked Factory gummies earned a respectable score of 4 out of 5 for their formulation, as well, due to the optimal dose of creatine. They use creatine monohydrate in the makeup, which is the most extensively studied form of creatine. 

Alternatives

We have to call out the sugar content with these creatine gummies from Jacked Factory. “8 grams of sugar is equivalent to eating two Starbursts or one Reese’s cup. While a treat like this is okay every now and then, considering creatine should be taken daily for optimal effects, this can be less than ideal for fitness enthusiasts,” says Destini Moody, RD, CSSD, LD. “Furthermore, it’s head-scratching why there are two different types of sugar (glucose syrup and white sugar) when the gummies are also sweetened with sucralose.” 

All that said, Jacked Factory must have heard the cries, because there is now a sugar-free option available. The Green Apple flavor is sweetened with maltitol, erythritol, and stevia leaf extract (which is still a lot of sweeteners). 

Jacked Factory also claims that these gummies are third-party tested, but there is no information as to who conducts the testing. We like to see third-party testing, but wish the company would disclose which lab is performing the trials. Accordingly, we rate these gummies at 3 out of 5 for third-party testing.

If you want another delicious gummy option that’s lower in added sugars, we recommend Swoly Creatine Gummies.

Testing Breakdown

Jacked Factory creatine gummies earned respectable scores across the board, with room for improvement in third-party testing.

Vs. The Average

Jacked Factory Creatine Gummies are much less expensive than the average of $1.47 per serving, and they still contain a full dose of creatine. 

At a Glance 

• Affordable cost per serving compared to other gummy options
• Only available in one flavor (strawberry)
• Five gummies per serving
• 4 g creatine per serving

For a great-tasting creatine gummy that will harken back to your childhood, Swoly has you covered with five gummy bears per serving (yes, gummy bears) that provide the recommended daily dose of creatine while managing to taste like the real candy.

Kate Meier, former GGR Senior Director of Content, tried the Swoly gummies alongside some members of her Olympic weightlifting team. She tells me they were a big hit, to say the least, which earned them a 5 out of 5 for taste and their rightful title as the best-tasting creatine gummies.

RELATED: Creatine Loading Phase: Is It Necessary?

Taste: 5/5

Third-Party Testing: 3/5

Price Per Serving: 3.5/5

Why We Like Swoly Creatine Gummies

“These are friggin delicious. Dangerously delicious. Like, need-to-make-sure-my-child-doesn’t-find-these-or-she-will-eat-them-all kind of delicious!” Kate says. “They remind me of the best fruit snacks ever (Annie’s Homegrown Organic fruit snacks). I’d eat these as a snack every day.” The texture earns top marks, as well, with another 5-out-of-5 rating in our trials.

Plus, these creatine monohydrate gummies pack a full clinical dose of creatine into five delicious, strawberry-flavored gummy bears. Each gummy contains a little less than 1 gram of creatine (0.8 grams per gummy, to be exact), and a five-gummy serving gets you to a 4-gram dose of creatine monohydrate.

Other ingredients include sucrose, dextrose, maltodextrin, natural and artificial flavors, stearic acid, and citric acid—ya know, things that make a gummy a gummy. Because of additives like artificial flavors, we rate Swoly at 4 out of 5 for its formulation.

Kate also noted no unwanted side effects (other than an addiction to the gummies, which she is only sort of joking about), and rated them a 5 out of 5 in that category. 

Alternatives

If you’re concerned about macros, you should know that there are 30 calories in a single serving of Swoly Creatine Gummies, including 2.5 grams of added sugar. Also, you’re hopefully a fan of Strawberry, as this is the only flavor available.

Additionally, competitive athletes should steer clear. Swoly gummies have a transparent and clear label, and are made in a Current Good Manufacturing Practice (cGMP) facility, but the brand does not disclose who does the stated third-party testing for contaminants or banned substances. For those with upcoming competitions on the horizon, it may be best to err on the side of caution. We rate them a 3 out of 5 for third-party testing.

If you want a bit more creatine out of your creatine gummies, try out Legion Naturally Sweetened & Flavored Creatine Monohydrate Gummies. Five gummies pack 5 grams of creatine in each serving.

Testing Breakdown

Swoly’s high overall rating comes from its high scores for taste, texture, and effects, along with customer experience.

Vs. The Average

Cheaper than average but far, far tastier than your typical creatine, Swoly Creatine Gummies can be a worthwhile venture for flavor-seeking individuals.

You can read more about this delicious supplement in our Swoly Creatine Gummies review.

At a Glance 

• 6 g of creatine per serving
• Vegan- and allergen-friendly formula
• High in sugar (8 g per serving)
• Three gummies per serving

If you’re wanting to branch out in the flavor department when it comes to your creatine supplement, I suggest Bounce Nutrition Creatine Gummies. Available in six flavors, they’re not only tasty, but some flavors are very unique, with options like Peach Rings and Berry Snow Cone. GGR Senior Staff Writer Caine Wilkes rated them a 4 out of 5 for taste.

Plus, you can bundle multiple containers together to try them all out (and save some money in the process). 

Taste: 4/5

Texture: 3.5/5

Third-Party Testing: 3/5

Why We Like Bounce Nutrition Creatine Gummies

Caine rates the Bounce Nutrition Creatine Gummies said he really enjoyed the (surprisingly mild) Cherry Lime flavor. 

Additionally, Caine—who also happens to be an Olympian from the 2020 Tokyo Games—appreciates the high creatine dose per serving of 6 grams, although it’s a little higher than the typical recommended dosage. “As a larger athlete, I usually take a higher dose of creatine, anyway, so I appreciate that Bounce doesn’t shy away from their dosage,” he states. 

For those wanting a smaller dosage, you can just take one less gummy and get 4 grams of creatine monohydrate from two gummies. While the formulation is solid with all-natural ingredients, there are 8 grams of added sugars in a serving, so the makeup gets a 4.5 out of 5 from us.

Those with dietary restrictions will appreciate that these Bounce Nutrition gummies are gluten-free, vegan, and non-GMO, too. They are also produced in an allergen-free facility and are free from milk, soy, wheat, egg, peanuts, tree nuts, fish, and crustacean shellfish. Caine didn’t experience any side effects after trying these gummies, rating them a 5 out of 5 in that category.

Alternatives

While Caine likes the understated flavor of the Cherry Lime gummies he tried, he’s a little on the fence when it comes to the texture. He rates the swallowability at 3.5 out of 5, adding, “You shouldn’t have these expecting a gummy bear texture.” The mouthfeel is closer to a chewable candy, but the consistency begins to break down only after a couple chomps. “It wasn’t unpleasant…just unexpected,” continues Caine.

Texture aside, one of the biggest drawbacks to these gummies is the price, with a three-gummy serving costing nearly $3. Because you can bundle these, you can drop the price per serving down to around $2, but you’ll have to buy at least five containers to save that much. 

That said, it can be a great way to explore the several flavor options offered by Bounce Nutrition. You can even bundle them with the brand’s pre-workout gummies for an all-in-one order experience. Bounce Nutrition also offers an industry-leading 60-day money-back guarantee, which is almost unheard of in the supplement category. 

If you really want to lean into that chewable candy experience, we suggest Animal Creatine Chews (which, as a bonus, are around $1 per serving).

Testing Breakdown

While we like a lot about Bounce Nutrition Creatine Gummies, the expensive price per serving brings the overall score down.

Vs. The Average

Bounce Nutrition Creatine Gummies are significantly more expensive than average if you take a full three-gummy serving. That said, they have a higher creatine dosage by 1.5 grams, and you have a roster of six different flavors to choose from. 

At a Glance 

• Very chewy texture, per our tester
• Includes tart cherry extract for recovery
• 3 g of creatine per serving
• Two-gummy serving size

If you enjoy chewy candy, you’ll love Organifi Creatine Chews, which rightfully earned their title as the best creatine chews. Our product tester and GGR team member Grant Smith tells me that the experience is “remarkably similar” to eating Swedish Fish. If that’s not the ideal chewy candy, I don’t know what is. On top of the delicious taste and texture—which both earned a perfect 5 out of 5 in testing—these chews provide a clinically backed dose of creatine in two gummies. 

RELATED: How Long Does Creatine Stay In Your System?

Formulation: 4/5

Taste: 5/5

Third-Party Testing: 3/5

Why We Like Organifi Creatine Chews

“It’s chewy, for sure, but breaks down a bit easier than your typical gummy bear,” Grant says. “The flavor is nice and sweet, but there is a hint of an aftertaste that’s not as pleasant.” 

This aforementioned aftertaste does dissipate rather quickly, though.

Organifi’s Creatine Cherry Chews are unique in that they actually use tart cherry extract in their chews, which I’m sure helps with the Cherry flavor, but it’s also there to aid with muscle recovery. Some studies¹ have shown that tart cherry juice may assist athletes with recovery after strenuous exercise. Along with 3 grams of creatine monohydrate in every two chews, this can help boost post-workout relief after an intense workout, so we score the formulation at 4 out of 5.

For those with dietary restrictions or specific preferences, Organifi chews are free from gluten, dairy, soy, and glyphosate—a known pesticide. 

Alternatives

Organifi Creatine Cherry Chews certainly get a plus for their unique formulation and clean, vegan-friendly ingredients. Still, they contain 3 grams of added sugars.

If there’s any major drawback to Organifi’s creatine gummies, it’s the price per serving, which we scored a 4 out of 5. At nearly $1.45 per serving, it’s on the pricey side for creatine supplements, though not far off from the average for creatine gummies. Nevertheless, you can save with a subscription through Organifi, which automatically keeps you stocked on a regular basis with repeat orders.

If you’re looking for a creatine chew that most closely resembles a Sweet Tart, we recommend Animal Creatine Chews, which pack 5 grams of creatine in four chewable tablets.

Testing Breakdown

Organifi Creatine Chews have a high overall rating, driven primarily by perfect 5-out-of-5 scores for taste, texture, effects, and customer reviews.

Vs. The Average

Organifi Creatine Chews are roughly on par with the average price of creatine gummies, though they contain less creatine per serving. 

At a Glance 

• Costs just over $1 per serving
• Texture is similar to a Sweet Tart
• Subscribe-and-save on Amazon
• 5 g creatine per serving

For a budget-conscious person who’d rather reach for a roll of Sweet Tarts over a bag of sour worms, Animal Creatine Chews might be for you. These are large, chewable tablets similar to Flintstones children’s multivitamins…If you know, you know. Plus, they cost just over $1 per serving, making them an affordable option for those seeking creatine powder alternatives. We awarded these Animal Creatine Chews a 4 out of 5 for price per serving.

Taste: 5/5

Texture: 4/5

Price Per Serving: 5/5

Why We Like Animal Creatine Chews

In those four chews per serving, you get 5 grams of creatine, meaning there are 1.25 grams of creatine per chew. Former GGR Senior Director of Content Kate Meier, NASM-CPT, USAW-L1, CF-L1 tried these, too, and had mixed thoughts on the taste and texture. 

“They are chalky, just like a Sweet Tart. You definitely need a drink after chewing these tablets,” Kate says. “They do dry your mouth out a little. It’s not a deal-breaker, but something to know.” She ultimately rated the taste at 5 out of 5, saying, “We tried the Fruit Punch, and thought it tasted like a Cherry Sweet Tart. Definitely tastes good enough that I would take these every day, kind of like how you look forward to taking gummy vitamins.”

In addition to creatine, these Animal chews also contain sea salt and AstraGin. Sea salt provides sodium, an important electrolyte, and AstraGin is a nutrient bioavailability enhancer that may increase uptake of nutrients it’s consumed with. 

The remaining ingredients are typical candy findings, such as sugar, dextrose, maltodextrin, stearic acid, natural and artificial flavors, magnesium stearate, citric acid, malic acid, and beet root powder for color. 

Of course, since this isn’t pure creatine, there are calories and carbs. These contain 3 grams of carbs per serving; 2 grams, of which, are from added sugar, so Animal Creatine Chews earn a 4 out of 5 for formulation.

RELATED: Can You Dry Scoop Creatine?

Alternatives

“You have to take four of these to get 5 grams of creatine, and they aren’t small tablets,” Kate notes in reference to the overall size of each chew. “My Olympic weightlifting teammate took all four at once, while I did two and two. I wouldn’t want to pop these in my mouth without something to wash it down.” Accordingly, she rates the swallowability at 4 out of 5.

Those concerned with the purity of their supplements should know that while the brand claims these chews are independently tested, there is no disclosure as to who does the testing. It’s impossible to know based on the information provided if the chews are tested for banned substances or specific contaminants. As such, we rate the third-party testing at a conservative 3 out of 5.

Avoiding sugar? Check out Jacked Factory Creatine Gummies, which have a sugar-free option available in Green Apple flavor.

Testing Breakdown

With 4s and 5s in virtually every tested category, Animal Creatine Chews stand out for their low cost per serving and strong formulation.

Vs. The Average

Budget-friendly and tasty, Animal Creatine Chews cost nearly $0.40 less per serving than the average creatine gummy. Yet, they still provide a full dose in each serving. 

At a Glance 

• Formula includes amino acids and B vitamins
• Included Huperzine A can help support in-gym focus
• 3 g creatine per serving
• 3-gummy serving

For anyone looking to build muscle, Bear Balanced Creatine Gummies can be an excellent choice. One serving of three gummies has 3 grams of creatine—the minimum clinically recommended dose to support muscle growth—and you can always eat one or two more for a 4- or 5-gram serving. These gummies also include a couple of other ingredients that have been shown to help with muscle growth, so we rated their formulation a 4.5 out of 5.

Plus, the gummies are made from Creapure, a micronized creatine monohydrate developed in Germany. Micronized creatine is made of smaller particles, which are supposed to help creatine mix more easily (a plus when turning the powder into gummy form) and help with absorption. 

RELATED: Proper Creatine Monohydrate Dosage

Price Per Serving: 3/5

Third-Party Testing: 5/5

Texture: 5/5

Why We Like Bear Balanced Creatine Gummies

Along with the clinical dose of creatine, the gummies have L-theanine and L-tyrosine, which have been shown to boost mental focus during exercise² and cognitive function. That said, the L-tyrosine is short of the researched-backed dosage of 2 grams³. The inclusion of Huperzine A may also help you focus in the gym and give more effort to each set, though research does not fully support that idea⁴. 

The non-GMO, gluten-free, and vegan-friendly creatine chews come in three flavors: Peach Mango, Watermelon, and Blueberry. Our tester tried Blueberry, which is the OG flavor, and said the taste was pretty spot-on for a blueberry gummy. As such, they gave the taste a 4 out of 5.

Our tester also liked the texture of the gummies and rated Bear Balanced at 5 out of 5 for the category, adding, “The mouthfeel was very nice, reminding me of actually gummy bears.” 

Finally, Bear Balanced Creatine Gummies are NSF Certified for Sport, which earns them a 5-point score for third-party testing.

Alternatives

While our tester was a fan of the Blue Raspberry flavor, they say, “There’s a definite artificial flavor that comes through, which may not be everyone’s cup of tea.” Just something to be aware of if you tend to be sensitive to things of that nature.

The price is also a concern of ours with this creatine supplement. The gummies cost $1.67 without the Bear Balanced subscription savings. Gummies are going to be more costly than creatine powder, but this is still pricier than average for gummies.

For a pure creatine supplement that’s still not a powder, we suggest Optimum Nutrition Micronized Creatine Capsules. Four capsules provide 5 grams of creatine.

Testing Breakdown

Bear Balanced Creatine Gummies earned high scores for formulation, texture, and third-party testing. Here are our full ratings, based on our detailed testing methodology:

Vs. The Average

We’d like to see a higher dose of creatine per serving, but Bear Balanced gummies still supply a clinically backed dose, albeit on the low end, compared to average. 

At a Glance 

• Sturdy elliptical with iFIT compatibility
• Heavier elliptical at 205 lbs
• Below-average 275-lb weight capacity
• 10-year frame warranty exceeds the standard

Available for just under the $1,000 threshold (you may be able to find it even cheaper during sales windows), the ProForm Carbon EL is our top overall pick because it offers tremendous value and performance without an inflated price tag. We particularly like that it syncs with iFIT, an interactive programming platform that offers over 10,000 on-demand courses catering to disciplines like cardio, strength, yoga, and more. Having utilized iFIT on some of the best treadmills, exercise bikes, and other cardio equipment, we rated the Carbon EL a perfect 5 out of 5 for dynamic programming. 

Value: 4.5/5

Footprint & Portability: 3.5/5

Tech Capabilities: 4.5/5

Why We Like the ProForm Carbon EL

With iFIT connectivity, Bluetooth speakers, and a multi-color, high-contrast display, the ProForm Carbon EL is one of the rare budget-friendly ellipticals that offers excellent tech features. In fact, it earns a near-perfect score of 4.5 out of 5 in this category thanks to its digital capabilities. 

From a comfort standpoint, this machine also checks an important box with an accommodating 19-inch adjustable stride length. Why does this matter? Taller athletes may need a longer stride length in order to achieve a full range of motion when using an elliptical. This is another rarity amongst budget-minded elliptical machines, as we rarely see models meet our threshold of an 18- to 20-inch stride length. Accordingly, we score the ProForm Carbon EL at 4 out of 5 for adjustability and ergonomics.

“The elliptical also has fixed and moving handles, so you can adjust your grip and your workout as you go,” says our expert product tester and former professional soccer player Caroline Lubinsky. 

Furthermore, the Carbon EL has cushioned foot pedals that offer three adjustable positions. This can be another nice feature you might not witness with other ellipticals at this price point. Add in 18 levels of resistance and a rock-solid 10-year frame warranty, and it’s easy to see why we rate this machine at 4.5 out of 5 for value. 

Alternatives

Although it’s by no means the biggest elliptical machine we’ve tested, the Carbon EL isn’t exactly the most portable profile, either. Tipping the scales at 205 pounds, we rated it a 3.5 out of 5 for its footprint and portability. Caroline used the front rollers to move the machine, but be warned that it’s a bit heavy and cumbersome during transport. 

In addition, while ProForm states that the 18 levels of magnetic resistance are “silent,” Caroline said she felt the noise was actually at a moderate level. So, if you’re looking for a whisper-quiet machine, this may not be it.

Finally, you’ll need to budget some time (and patience) to put this machine together. Caroline rated the delivery and setup at 3 out of 5, describing the process as “annoying.” 

“It’d be best completed with a friend because of the many pieces,” she told me.

If space is an issue, you could go with the ultra-compact Cubii Move. However, keep in mind that this under-desk elliptical will give you more of a mini stair stepper feel than a traditional elliptical training experience.

Testing Breakdown

Here’s how the ProForm Carbon EL fared, based on our elliptical testing methodology.

Vs. The Average

The ProForm Carbon EL is more affordable than the average elliptical machine and has a substantially better warranty package. However, it falls a bit short in weight capacity by 55 pounds. 

You can read more in our full ProForm Carbon EL review.

At a Glance 

• Budget-friendly elliptical with 10 available resistance levels
• Smaller flywheel weight than the average
• Below-average weight capacity
• Lifetime frame warranty

Earning a rock-solid overall rating of 4 out of 5 from GGR Everything lead reviewer Lindsay Scheele, CPT, CNC, the Horizon EX-59 can be a smart investment for home gym owners looking for a long-term cardio solution. With a sturdy build that supports users up to 300 pounds, you can attack your elliptical workouts with supreme confidence. This is also one of the most comfortable machines we’ve gotten our hands (and feet) on, as Linday rates it at 4 out of 5 for adjustability and ergonomics, noting, “It certainly is not as sturdy as a commercial model, but I was really happy with the stability for the price and size.” 

Footprint & Portability: 4/5

Ergonomics: 4/5

Value: 4/5

Why We Like the Horizon Fitness EX-59

Despite its budget-friendly price tag, the EX-59 provides a smooth, stable workout experience you might not expect given the sub-$1,000 price tag. “This is super smooth,” Lindsay told me. “There was no shifting when I took it to top speeds.” This workout efficiency was even more impressive given the EX-59’s lighter 14-pound flywheel. For reference, lighter flywheels can oftentimes be more erratic and loud when training at higher intensities, so we appreciate the performance aspects of this Horizon Fitness build.

The textured foot pedals also help you maintain your footing as you exercise, and an 18-inch stride length means this machine can be accommodating enough for users of just about any height. The EX-59 also has fixed and moving handlebars, opening the door to full-body workouts. 

We also appreciate that the EX-59 has a bunch of user-friendly conveniences, including built-in speakers, a USB charging port, three water bottle holders, and a media shelf for DIY streaming setups. As a result, we award it a 4 out of 5 in this category.

Although this machine is longer than the average elliptical by nearly a foot, it still earns a strong footprint and portability score of 4 out of 5. This stems from the fact that it’s easy to move with the front transport wheels and rear handle. So, if you want to move the EX-59 when you’re done breaking a sweat, you shouldn’t have any trouble. “The wheels make it doable for me to move alone,” adds Lindsay. “It felt smaller and easier than a commercial machine.”

Alternatives

One of the few areas where the EX-59 didn’t blow us away was customizations. We rated it a 3 out of 5 since there’s only 10 levels of magnetic resistance and no adjustable incline settings. Again, that shouldn’t be a complete surprise given the price point, but it does limit its versatility when compared to other ellipticals. 

The EX-59 also falls a bit short in tech capabilities, earning a 3.5 out of 5 for the category. It has a basic display with three LED windows that show your workout metrics…and that’s about it. Luckily, there is a device holder so you can stream your favorite shows or workout apps. That said, for athletes interested in training with the latest tech features and conveniences, this is not the silhouette for such desires.

If you want a more high-tech elliptical, check out the ProForm Carbon EL. This similarly-priced machine earned a near-perfect score of 4.5 out of 5 for tech capabilities, as well as a 5-out-of-5 rating for dynamic programming.

Testing Breakdown

Here’s how the Horizon EX-59 scored based on our testing methodology. As you can see, it met our threshold for a 3 out of 5 in every examined category. 

Vs. The Average

The Horizon Fitness EX-59 is more affordable than the average elliptical by roughly $300. That said, you do make some sacrifices in weight capacity and flywheel weight. 

For more insight, read our in-depth Horizon EX-59 elliptical review.

At a Glance 

• Unparalleled weight capacity
• Inferior warranty compared to average elliptical
• Feels secure and stable in use
• Free shipping and 30-day money-back guarantee

The YOSUDA EM1 Long-Stride Magnetic Elliptical Machine is available in two models: the Glide (18.91-inch stride length) or the Glide Select (20.09-inch stride length). Both machines offer a quiet workout experience thanks to a smooth magnetic drive system. Most impressively, though, the Glide boasts a 400-pound weight capacity (the Glide Select ups that to 500 pounds), helping it earn a perfect durability score of 5 out of 5. We chose this as the best compact elliptical since the EM1 occupies just 8.6 square feet, which is smaller than most coffee tables. 

Durability: 5/5

Value: 4/5

Footprint & Portability: 4/5

Why We Like the YOSUDA EM1 Long-Stride Magnetic Elliptical Machine

Measuring just over 4 feet long, roughly 2 feet wide, and a shade over 5 feet high, the EM1 definitely meets our standards for a compact elliptical machine. This makes it ideal for home gym owners with limited room. Despite the smaller-than-average dimensions, though, our expert product tester stated their training experience was comfortable, effective, and downright pleasant.

“The stride going forward feels very much like running,” she told me. “Going backwards, the stride feels smooth, but more of a glide than a run. I enjoyed the workout versatility, and I would use this machine again for fun or for elderly clients.”

The compact framing also lends itself to efficient portability. Our tester rated the EM1 Long-Stride Magnetic Elliptical Machine at 4 out of 5 for the category, noting, “It’s not a heavy machine, but it’s not light either. The machine is top-heavy when you’re rolling it, but for me, it was easy to move.” 

The aptly-named Glide series also proved to be quiet during operation. Our tester said the steps and handles moved smoothly through their range of motion with limited noise, though the resistance knob does have some audible feedback when you turn it. That said, our tester appreciated the easy-to-use adjustment mechanism that made mid-workout resistance changes a breeze.

Alternatives

Unfortunately, this YOSUDA product left us wanting more in a few key areas. First, the display is lackluster, resulting in a 3-out-of-5 tech capabilities score. “The font is easy to read, but the screen is not like an iPhone; it’s more like a GameBoy from the ‘90s,” our tester notes. “It’s a simple green and black display versus a blue light touch screen. You can only look at one thing on the screen at a time, too.” 

Perhaps the most disappointing aspect, though, is the lack of built-in programming. While other models on this list feature 10+ programs, you get nothing with the Yosuda EM1. “You are on your own just doing it for time, distance, or calories,” our tester told me. 

Luckily, the Glide connects via Bluetooth to iConsole+, Kinomap, and the FED app for some digital programming options. You also get a free year of FED premium courses; a nice bonus that adds a bit of value. Overall, though, we only rate the programming at 2.5 out of 5 since there aren’t any built-in workouts to choose from.

If you want a robust range of programming options, we highly recommend the Schwinn 430, which features 22 built-in workouts. 

Testing Breakdown

Here’s how the YOSUDA EM1 performed during testing. We were highly impressed with its durability and portability, but felt underserved by the included tech and programming.

Vs. The Average

The YOSUDA EM1 Long-Stride Magnetic Elliptical Machine is slightly cheaper than the average elliptical. While we’re impressed with its best-in-class weight capacity, we’re somewhat disappointed in its inferior one-year warranty.

At a Glance 

• One of the most affordable ellipticals on the market
• Below-average 13-lb flywheel weight
• Average 330-lb weight capacity
• 3-year frame warranty

If you are just starting to experiment with elliptical training, you may want a machine that is straightforward and accessible. Available for roughly $550, the Sunny Health & Fitness SF-E3912 Magnetic Elliptical can be ideal for beginners looking to learn the ins and outs of this cardio modality. GGR Senior Director of Content Kate Meier used this machine for several workouts and can attest to how simple it is in operation. 

“I like this Sunny Health offering for beginners because there are a whopping 24 easy-to-follow programs, so you don’t have to come up with your own beginner elliptical workout,” she told me in reference to her 4-out-of-5 programming rating. Plus, we think this is one of the best elliptical machines in terms of value, rating the SF-E3912 at 4.5 out of 5 for the category; you’re paying less than half of the average elliptical yet still get a sturdy machine with industry standard specs.

Durability: 5/5

Dynamic Programming: 4/5

Footprint & Portability: 4/5

Why We Like the Sunny Health & Fitness Magnetic Elliptical Machine

This Sunny Health & Fitness machine actually earned a perfect durability score despite the preconceived notion that cheap machines aren’t well-built. Unlike similarly priced ellipticals, this model can accommodate heavier users with a 330-pound weight capacity. This is especially impressive since the elliptical has a compact footprint of 55 inches long by 23 inches wide by 64.5 inches high and only weighs 104.8 pounds. Most importantly, the machine remains stable during use, according to Kate. “During my workouts, I pedaled forward and backward, and I noticed only minimal shifting while in use,” she told me. 

With an electro-magnetic system, the Sunny Magnetic Elliptical offers 16 levels of resistance that can be utilized via the center console. Beginner athletes can efficiently ease into a training session, slowly increasing workout intensities through their warm-up and working circuits. We also like that this machine offers both stationary and moving handlebars, which can offer stability for those just getting used to an elliptical as well as upper-body workout potential for when you’re ready to progress. As a result, we rate the customizations at a 4 out of 5. 

The backlit display is basic but reports the essentials like your heart rate, speed, calories burned, and distance. Also, if you need more from your monitor, the machine’s built-in media shelf can be helpful to safely incorporate your devices for additional training guidance or entertainment. Accordingly, we rate the conveniences at a 4 out of 5.  

Alternatives

While Sunny Health & Fitness deserves credit for building such a durable yet wallet-friendly machine, it’s fair to point out that the stride length of 15.5 inches is on the short side; taller users may not be quite as comfortable with the SF-E3912. As someone who stands 6 feet, 2 inches in height, I’d be hesitant about relying on this silhouette for regular training. As such, we rate the ergonomics at 3.5 out of 5. 

Kate relayed that her experience with putting the SF-E3912 together wasn’t exactly a breeze, either. “I personally assembled this machine, and it took about 1.5 hours,” she told me. “The instructions had complicated diagrams that combined several steps into one. I’ve put together commercial-grade ellipticals before and didn’t have this many issues.”

For a particular paint point of the setup, Kate notes that attaching the pedals requires some finesse and reworking screws to get it right. Sunny Health provides the tools necessary, but Kate found it easier to use her own Philips head screwdriver. Since you do get free shipping, we still rate the delivery and setup process at a 4 out of 5. 

Concerned about the SF-E3912’s stride length? Taller folks should look into the Horizon Fitness EX-59, which has an 18-inch stride length that should feel more comfortable if you’re vertically gifted. 

Testing Breakdown

The Sunny Health and Fitness Magnetic Elliptical Machine scored at least a 3 in all of the performance-related categories we assess. 

Vs. The Average

The Sunny Health & Fitness Magnetic Elliptical is substantially cheaper than the average elliptical machine by more than 50%. Despite weighing just over 100 pounds, it boasts the same user weight capacity as machines that weigh about 75 pounds more. 

For more information on this budget-friendly machine, check out our Sunny Health & Fitness Magnetic Elliptical review.

At a Glance 

• Affordable under-desk elliptical with available free shipping
• LCD screen that tracks time, stride count, mileage, and calories burned
• Average 300-lb weight capacity
• Under-desk orientation does not support upper-body exercises

We know the Cubii Move doesn’t look like an elliptical; it’s a small pedaling machine (similar to a mini stair stepper) that can be stored under your desk (just like an under-desk treadmill) or kept at your feet while you watch TV. That said, this unconventional yet ultra-compact cardio tool can be a great way to support a healthy, active lifestyle if you spend most of your day on the computer. We rate the Cubii Move’s value at 4.5 out of 5, too, since it costs about the same as a few tubs of your favorite protein powder.

Footprint & Portability: 5/5

Durability: 3.5/5

Ergonomics: 4/5

Why We Like the Cubii Move

We’re BIG fans of compact exercise equipment, and the Cubii Move certainly qualifies as that. Measuring just under 2 feet long, 19.7 inches wide, and 9.7 inches high, this under-desk cardio machine takes up as much room as a few pairs of dumbbells. Plus, it only tips the scales at 17 pounds, meaning you can easily reposition it for that picture perfect setup. 

“There aren’t any wheels on it, but it’s light enough for most people to handle and move around in your home or office,” our tester told me, rating the Move a 5 out of 5 for footprint and portability. 

Of course, you shouldn’t expect the same type of workout experience from an under-desk model as a traditional, full-sized machine. After all, there are no handlebars for upper-body engagement. Still, our product tester was impressed with how comfortable the Cubii Move is to use, rating the adjustability and ergonomics at 4 out of 5. 

“The pedaling is smooth and feels comfortable—worth while for under-desk elliptical training,” our tester told me.

Although the Cubii Move does not offer incline adjustment settings, it does have six levels of toggleable resistance. Remember, you’re not relying on this for high-intensity training; rather, this is a device you can utilize during work hours without causing any interference to your scheduled phone calls, video conferences, or digital meetings. 

Alternatives

Inherently limited in its capabilities, it’s still fair to want a bit more from the Cubii Move in terms of customizations. Six levels of resistance sounds good, in theory, but in practice, it left us a bit underwhelmed, resulting in a 3-out-of-5 rating for the category. Our tester had to leave it set on the highest settings, noting, “I hardly felt any difference between the levels.” 

Although this ultra-budget, under-desk elliptical has a 300-pound weight capacity, we wouldn’t call it the most durable machine. The Cubii Move features tons of plastic parts, so you run the risk of cracking the plastic if you’re not mindful of how you handle it during transport and training. We still give it a 3.5 out of 5 for durability, but it’s definitely something to be aware of. 

If you prefer a standard elliptical machine yet still need a compact profile for smaller spaces, we recommend the Sunny Health and Fitness Magnetic Elliptical, which earned a 4 out of 5 for footprint and portability. 

Testing Breakdown

The Cubii Move earned solid scores across the board, though we acknowledge it’s not an apples-to-apples comparison with the other entries on our list of the best ellipticals under $1,000.

Editor’s Note: Since this is an under-desk elliptical, we did not factor in conveniences or dynamic programming into our overall rating.

Vs. The Average

To put this into proper perspective, we compared the Cubii Move to your typical under-desk elliptical machine. As you can see, it’s on par or exceeds the averages in every category.

At a Glance 

• Streamlined console with multiple screens
• 20 levels of computer-controlled resistance
• Slightly below-average weight capacity
• Above-average warranty

It’s nice to simply step onto a cardio machine, press a button, and get right into a good workout. That’s precisely what you can do on the Schwinn 430, which offers a whopping 22 built-in programs catering to a range of training interests! These modules include beginner- and advanced-level options for workouts such as heart rate control, fitness tests, and customized sessions. This results in an easy score of 5 out of 5 for dynamic programming, as you can use the 430 for intense elliptical workouts for runners or more casual, steady-state sessions.

Editor’s Note: We have not tested the 430 elliptical in our facilities, but we have been able to test the Schwinn 470—a since-discontinued model that should give you a good feel of what to expect from the budget-friendly 430.

Customizations: 4/5

Value: 4/5

Dynamic Programming: 5/5

Why We Like the Schwinn 430 Elliptical

One of the downsides with the sub-$1,000 price range is that it limits your ability to stream workouts through an app. Luckily, the Schwinn 430 stands apart from other similarly priced ellipticals by offering a whopping 22 built-in workout programs. Having this library conveniently at your fingertips can be great for promoting regular challenges and workout progression without the need for a secondary subscription. As a result, we rate it a rock-solid 4 out of 5 for value. 

In addition to being packed with workouts, the 430 is loaded with features, as well. You’ll find a USB port, media shelf, water bottle holder, a cooling fan, dual speakers, and even an input for MP3 devices. We had no complaints regarding similar conveniences on the Schwinn 470 during our testing. We also appreciate the two DualTrack LCD displays that allow you to view programs and goal tracking. Overall, we rate the conveniences at a 3.5 out of 5. 

Both the 470 that we tested and the 430 have the same type of magnetic resistance, as well as a 20-inch stride length (which can be a big plus for taller users). In testing, we found the 470 to be extremely quiet, and we can speculate that with similar specs, the 430 will be just as silent. There are 20 levels of resistance on the 430, and it is computer controlled; in other words, you can simply press buttons to change the resistance. 

Alternatives

Be warned: This is not a compact machine in the least bit. Conversely, it’s rather large measuring nearly 6 feet long and more than 2 feet wide, meaning you’ll need sufficient space to fit this in your home gym or office; make sure to measure ahead of time. Plus, the Schwinn 430 weighs nearly 170 pounds, leading to a footprint and portability score of 3.5 out of 5. 

There are two other callouts worth mentioning. First, the 430 lacks Bluetooth connectivity, which can be a hindrance if you like to sync your fitness tracker with your cardio machine for effective data monitoring. Secondly, while many companies offer free shipping, that’s not the case with Schwinn. Be prepared to pay $199 for shipping, which elevates the overall investment total to over the $1,000 threshold. However, you can still find the 430 on other retailers that may offer free shipping, so check all your options before you make a final decision.

If you’re concerned about the lack of connectivity, look into the ProForm Carbon EL, which has Bluetooth speakers for an enhanced workout experience.

Testing Breakdown

Here’s how the Schwinn 430 Elliptical measured up, based on our testing protocols. 

Vs. The Average

The Schwinn 430 Elliptical is about $300 cheaper than the average elliptical. We appreciate the superior warranty coverage but would be remiss without pointing out that the flywheel is much lighter than the average machine, which can lead to louder mid-workout performances. 

At a Glance 

• Offers both prepared meals and meal kits
• Starts at budget-friendly pricing
• Average amount of meals per week
• Below-average number of available meal plans

Home Chef is our best overall pick for high-protein meals for many reasons, but the one that impresses us most is the flavor, which we gave a perfect 5-out-of-5 score. With fresh ingredients and chef-crafted recipes, dishes are designed to be portioned well and satisfying. Some meals are packed with 30 grams of protein or more, making this meal kit service the ideal choice for those who want nutritious meals that taste just as good as they are good for you.

Taste: 5/5

Variety: 5/5

Ease of Prep: 2/5

Why We Like Home Chef

Emily Chidester, a friend of Garage Gym Reviews who has been using Home Chef for nearly two years, praised the consistently tasty flavors, though she told me that the deliciousness of each dish will depend on your personal cooking skills. “Many of the meals have wonderful sauces that just make the food absolutely perfect,” she told me. “My family has learned a lot about cooking just from making different recipes.”

Home Chef has a rotating menu of meals with some reaching 30 to 40 grams of protein per serving. The service also offers a variety of calorie- and carb-conscious meals that can be tailored to your dietary preferences. You can even swap in leaner meats on some recipes, such as chicken in place of sausage. Plus, as registered dietitian Perry Nix points out, cooking your own meals, even those from a meal kit, has been linked to improved diet quality.

“Home Chef is a good option for those wanting to learn how to build balanced meals and acquire new cooking skills,” Nix says. “Even if you only use the meal kits short-term, you can mimic the recipes in the future by using store-bought ingredients.”

Emily also rates Home Chef’s ordering process at 5 out of 5. “I get email reminders every week to go select my meals,” she says. “Home Chef automatically selects meals for you based on your stated preferences and the types of meals you’ve selected in the past, but you can edit them if you want.”

Alternatives

The ease of preparation can depend on the recipe in question, though Emily gave the service a 2 out of 5 for the category, mostly because it requires a good bit of cleanup post-dining. The meal kits can take anywhere from 20 to 40 minutes, but there are ‘Express’ meals that can be ready in 15 minutes or less, as well as ‘Oven-Ready’ meals that you just need to heat and eat.

Emily also let me know that Home Chef has made some mistakes before with regards to her delivered orders, typically in the form of sending her the wrong meal kits or ingredients. Still, in those moments, customer service was very receptive and helpful, applying credits to her account for the next delivery. Because of this, the packaging and shipping earns a 3.5 out of 5, while customer service gets a solid 5-out-of-5 score.

We love Home Chef, but if you prefer not to cook or clean after eating, consider a company like Tempo Meals, which focuses on pre-made meals.

Testing Breakdown

In short, Home Chef is a solid meal kit service we recommend, although the varying prep time impacted its overall score a bit.

Vs. The Average

With prices starting below $8, Home Chef is certainly a less expensive meal service when compared to the average meal delivery. Plus, it offers meal kits and prepared meals—a rare sense of variety for the category.

Read our Home Chef review for more information.

At a Glance

• Prepared meal delivery service with high-protein options
• Meals are within standard price range
• Can order 16 or more meals per week, well above the norm
• Average number of meal plans available

It’s no secret that adequate protein intake is one key component of building muscle. Amino acids—the building blocks of proteins—are crucial for muscle synthesis and repair³. With meals that contain close to 30 grams of protein, Tempo by Home Chef is our top pick for a high-protein meal delivery service for athletes. Tempo is also the official meal delivery of the CrossFit Games, further justifying its effectiveness for sport-minded individuals.

Nutrition and supplements expert Bob Iafelice, MS, RDN, LDN, approves of this service, which we rate at 4 out of 5 overall. “Protein is the core of a meal, and Tempo by Home Chef does it right by placing a large emphasis on protein,” he tells me. “The meals are well-balanced, too, with plenty of veggies.” 

Ease of Prep: 5/5

Plans & Customizations: 2/5

Taste: 4.5/5

Why We Like Tempo Meals

Former GGR editorial member and certified personal trainer Anthony O’Reilly rated the meals at a solid 4.5 out of 5 for taste. “I was surprised by how much I liked these. There was a ton of flavor, and you can tell everything is well-seasoned,” he says.

Anthony was also impressed with the ingredient quality, scoring the meals at 4 out of 5 for the category. “Everything seems fresh, but the ingredients aren’t organic,” Anthony explained to me. “The meals are a lot better than other prepared meal services I’ve tried, though.” 

RELATED: Best Meat Subscription Boxes

Tempo by Home Chef offers a broad variety of meals, and you can even choose certain foods you’d like to avoid during signup (no cluttered menus, hooray!). Anthony was also a fan of the easy preparation process and rated it at 5 out of 5. The simple prep and lack of cleanup can be great for athletes (or anyone) that are constantly on the move, too.

Alternatives

There’s no easy way to select meals that fit a specific dietary need when choosing your preferences—like if you need to eat gluten-free, for example. You’ll have to pay close attention to the ingredients when choosing your weekly servings if you have a food allergy, as the nutrition information doesn’t specify allergens. Because of this, Tempo gets a 2 out of 5 on meal plans and customizations.

Another callout is the price per meal, which Anthony rated at 3 out of 5. Costs can range from around $11 to $13.50, depending on how many meals you order. You can choose up to 16 or more meals each week, and the price per meal decreases the more you order. Still, the cost can quickly add up, and Anthony didn’t think the quality quite matched the pricing.

If you want something a little more affordable, you may want to look into services that provide meal kits you assemble yourself, like Home Chef.

Testing Breakdown

Aside from the lack of diet-specific meal plans, Tempo Meals is a solid (albeit pricey) meal delivery service that scored quite well in our testing.

Vs. The Average

Prices vary depending on the number of meals you order each week, but the price range falls around the average price per meal when compared to typical costs. Also, Tempo Meals offers four different meal plans—slightly over the usual three options provided by many meal deliveries—although they aren’t necessarily diet-specific. Those with restrictions or allergies will still need to pay close attention to the meals they order.

At a Glance

• Prepared meals available in the contiguous U.S.
• Priced near the average meal service
• Above-average number of meal plans, including Protein Plus
• Choose between 6 and 18 meals per week—an above-average range

Factor is one of the most popular prepared meal services on the market, and for good reason. Along with being a convenient option that’s easy to prep, they offer excellent portion sizes, ample variety, and high-quality ingredients. You can also order anywhere from six to 18 meals each week, covering various people’s needs.

Additionally, there are plenty of high-protein options to help fuel your gains, including an entire menu dubbed ‘Protein Plus,’ where each meal contains at least 30 grams of protein per serving.

“These meals can fill up a triathlete in the middle of a tough training block, so they can likely fill up just about anyone,” says GGR Senior Staff Writer and former competitive triathlete Amanda Capritto, CPT, CES, CNC, CF-L1, CSNC, rating Factor’s portion sizes at 4.5 out of 5.

Taste: 4/5

Variety: 4/5

Sustainability: 2/5

Why We Like Factor

Our tester Amanda is also from New Orleans, so she told me she hit most of her Factor meals with some Tony Chachere’s seasoning (if you know, you know). Nevertheless, she rated the taste at a solid 4 out of 5, and mentioned to me that the proteins impressed her most of all. “The steaks were actually pink in the middle, even after microwaving, and didn’t turn into shoe leather, so shoutout to Factor for that,” she explained.

Factor has eight distinct meal plans—Protein Plus, Chef’s Choice, Calorie Smart, Keto, Carb Conscious, GLP-1 Balance, Fiber Filled, Flexitarian—but there is some crossover between them. For example, a Protein Plus meal might also be classified as a Keto meal. 

Because of this versatility, you’ll get to choose from around 30 different meals each week (there are closer to 35 total, but they don’t all fall under the high-protein category). If you want to mix and match, you have that option, too. Even if you sign up for a dedicated meal plan, you’ll still get access to the full weekly menu, which is why Factor earns a 4-out-of-5 rating for variety. 

The menu changes weekly, although you might see some repeat favorites, and Amanda let me know that quite a few meals have a similar set-up: a protein with veggies and grains. 

RELATED: Factor Vs HelloFresh

In addition to meals, you can opt for add-ons like coconut pancakes, bacon and cheddar egg bites, and garlic buffalo chicken wings—all of which fall under the Protein Plus meal plan. There are also cooked bulk meats and fish if you want extra protein as an accompanying side dish.

Alternatives

Where Factor scored lowest in our testing was in its sustainability efforts, mostly because, well, they don’t seem to put much effort into sustainability. Amanda rates it at a 2 out of 5 and tells me that it didn’t score lower since Factor’s packaging doesn’t seem glaringly different from other, more sustainable meal delivery services.

“The main difference, I suppose, is that each Factor meal comes in its own plastic tray, which is definitely a bit wasteful compared to cooking at home,” she adds.

Additionally, the price per serving is right on the average, costing between $11 and $14 per serving. Factor earns a 3 out of 5 for its middle-of-the-road price point, but the convenience should make it worthwhile for quite a few people.

If you’re looking for pre-portioned meal kits to prepare yourself rather than pre-made meals, we recommend trying Home Chef.

Testing Breakdown

Despite its lack of sustainability efforts, Factor can be a great option for protein-packed prepared meals each day. Here’s how it scored, according to our testing methodology.

Vs. The Average

Factor costs around your average meal delivery service, depending on the number of meals you order each week. There is more flexibility in Factor than other meal deliveries, too, as there are more meal plans for dietary preferences. Plus, you can order up to 18 meals a week, which is well above the average metric.

For more, check out our in-depth Factor Meals review.

At a Glance 

• Nationwide delivery
• More expensive than average price per meal
• Order minimum of 7 meals per week
• An above-average amount of available meal plans

While many meal delivery services send pre-made meals, Fuel Meals earned the spot of best prepared high-protein meal delivery for its ease of prep and ordering, as well as its balanced macros. “The meals are high-protein, low-fat, and include a moderate amount of carbs,” says registered dietitian Perry Nix. “This balance supports muscle growth and provides enough energy to help you power through your workout.” 

Furthermore, cooking the food couldn’t be simpler, earning a 5 out of 5 for ease of preparation: Just throw your pre-packaged serving in the microwave and it’s done within three minutes.

RELATED: Fuel Meals Discount Code

Ease of Prep: 5/5

Taste: 4/5

Portion Size: 4/5

Why We Like Fuel Meals

We had two certified personal trainers test out Fuel Meals, and both awarded the service a 4 out of 5 on flavor. “The taste is all totally fine and completely edible; I could order and eat it again,” Kate Meier, GGR’s Senior Director of Content and a fellow competitive weightlifter, told me. “But I found myself adding vegetables to the meal, or adding a sauce or a spice to get more out of it.”

Nicole Davis, a Precision Nutrition coach and GGR Director of Content Quality, agreed and found that the meats were typically good, while the sides were oftentimes lackluster. “It was typically just sweet potatoes or potatoes with not much to them,” she says.

You can pick between seven and 20 meals per week, with the nutritional information displayed front and center as you’re scrolling through each week’s menu. The nutritional information is also on meal labels, although Kate noted that each label featured a blurred print. Nicole had no issues, though, so Fuel Meals earns a 4 out of 5 for access to nutrition information.

Alternatives

Perry Nix adds that one downside of Fuel meals is that it might not be for adventurous eaters, since their meals consist of traditional “prep” foods—chicken, rice, broccoli, potatoes, etc. There’s nothing wrong with any of those, but some people may prefer a little more variety, which is why we gave Fuel Meals a 3 out of 5 in that category. That said, there are also prepared proteins available by the pound to save time on meal prepping, along with snacks like chocolate protein brownies. 

This is also a pricier meal delivery service with meals starting around $14. For comparison, we’ve determined the average meal delivery service to cost roughly $12.37 per serving. As such, it earns a 2 out of 5 for price per serving.

If you’re looking for a meal delivery service that offers more variety, we recommend trying Factor instead.

Testing Breakdown

Albeit a pricier meal delivery, this prepared meals service scored quite well in its ease of ordering and prep. Below is a breakdown of its scores.

Vs. The Average

With meals between $14 and $16, this is one of the pricier high-protein meal deliveries on our list, although the nationwide delivery does make this accessible to states like Alaska and Hawaii.

Check out our full Fuel Meals review for more information.

At a Glance 

• Meal kit service delivering to the contiguous U.S.
• Less expensive price per serving
• Above average meals per week
• Accommodates an above-average amount of dietary needs

Looking for variety? You’ve found it with Hungryroot, which is basically a meal kit delivery service and online grocery store mashed into one. When signing up, you take a quiz outlining your preferences and dietary needs, and Hungryroot will automatically load hundreds of recipes that work for you, earning 5 out of 5 stars for variety.

“You essentially shop for meals and groceries at the same time each week, and you pick things you like and remove things you don’t want,” adds Kate Meier, CPT, USAW-L1, CF-L1, and GGR Senior Director of Content. “Any item you’d want, it’s more than likely available on Hungryroot.”

Ease of Prep: 4/5

Variety: 5/5

Ordering: 3/5

Why We Like Hungryroot

Hungryroot acts like a meal kit service, since you can filter recipes by protein type or cook time. When you see a recipe you like, you can add it to your cart, and all the necessary ingredients will load for you. However, you can also shop the site like an online grocery store, adding proteins, organic produce, spices, sauces, cheeses, and most other ingredients that you’d find in a supermarket. This only adds to the variety and brings a uniqueness to the shopping experience, as a whole.

The majority of the recipes take around 10 minutes or less since Hungryroot relies on a lot of pre-cooked (but high-quality) ingredients. Kate tested Hungryroot and was a big fan of the ingredient quality and the taste of the meals she tried (which she confirmed took less than 10 minutes to prepare). She gave Hungryroot a 4.5 out of 5 for ingredient quality and a 4 out of 5 for ease of preparation.

RELATED: Hungryroot vs. HelloFresh

“Hungryroot helps you find the best plan for your dietary needs and preferences. They include groceries and recipes made without common food allergens, like soy, nuts, shellfish, and eggs, which is hard to find in other meal service plans,” registered dietitian Perry Nix said to me.

Alternatives

If there’s a major complaint with Hungryroot, it can be from the initial quiz upon signing up. It’s a thorough quiz, covering most aspects you can think of like how much you enjoy cooking, what style of cuisine you enjoy (Thai, Italian, or Mexican, for example), and flavors or foods you dislike. They fill up your cart based on your quiz, and then you can edit it for up to six days.

Kate admitted to me, “The process is, honestly, a bit confusing. I’m almost not sure if I’m getting recipes or groceries.” The answer, in reality, is you’re getting both, but the initial ordering process can certainly be overwhelming to some, which is why it scores a 3 out of 5 in the category.

For a simpler ordering process, you may want to consider a company like Trifecta, which ships frozen meals that can be stored in the freezer. It has a pretty straightforward ordering process, as well.

Testing Breakdown

Hungryroot is a favorite among the meal delivery services we’ve tested. Although the initial ordering and quiz can be daunting, it scored well, overall.

Vs. The Average

Because of the unique ordering experience of Hungryroot, prices can vary per meal, but in our experience, they average out below the standard and sit around $10 per meal. The company also allows for filtering through several dietary needs and preferences, which is a customization not typically shared among common meal subscription services.

For more information, read our in-depth Hungryroot review.

At a Glance 

• Nationwide delivery range
• Pricier meal delivery service when to average costs
• Can order an above-average number of meals each week
• Above-average amount of available meal plans

Trifecta doesn’t have a dedicated high-protein meal service, per se, but the company does offer a clean meal plan, a paleo/Whole30-approved plan, and a keto diet plan—all of which have around 30 to 40 grams of protein per meal, at the very least. (If you prefer plant-based protein, there’s also a high-protein vegan plan, but the protein per meal averages slightly lower at around 20 grams.) 

With its solid keto and low-carb options, Trifecta earns our spot as the best keto meal delivery service for high-protein meals, and it earns a 4 out of 5 for meal plans and customizations; along with a keto meal plan, you can choose between paleo, Whole30, and high-protein vegan or vegetarian meal plans.